Going Natural with Homemade Nutella

Last Spring we took a family trip to Paris.  Besides falling in love with the splendor and beauty that often defines the city of lights, my daughter also fell in love with Nutella.  Wherever we went, she’d seek out a creperie or a crepe cart on the street to order up a hot crepe, overflowing with Nutella – sometimes bananas and strawberries were mixed in too. Although Nutella tastes very chocolate-y and looks like chocolate, it’s not chocolate!  It’s actually a hazelnut spread.  I couldn’t wait to support her seemingly healthy Nutella habit back in the U.S. I marched right into the grocery store and purchased some jars of Nutella.  After all, we had a new food item to add into her meal rotations.  I wasn’t focused on the actual ingredients.

It wasn’t until I was watching television the other night, 7 months after my daughter embarked on her Nutella journey, that I learned Nutella is actually LOADED with sugar.  I guess I could’ve just looked at the back label. That would’ve saved me a few hundred Challah-and-Nutella sandwiches.  I was a bit concerned.

Now, I am not going to pretend to be Laura Ingall’s Wilder.  My house is certainly not pure.  I don’t make my own playdoh from flour, nor do I press my fruits every morning to make juice and I’ve never chopped cucumbers to create the perfect eye cream paste.  However, I am becoming more aware of what I’m putting in my kids’ bodies.  I still don’t read every label but, when something so grossly out of balance, like the sugar content in my daughter’s 10 heaping spoonfuls of Nutella every morning, I am starting to feel like it’s my duty to try to come up with a healthier alternative.

It’s funny, my knee-jerk reaction to the Nutella sugar content has absolutely nothing to do with the method in which my mom cooked.  In fact, she never substituted any of her ingredients to offer up a healthier alternative.  What’s changed is simply my awareness.  Now that I’m cooking more and strategically shopping for the ingredients for our meals, I’m actually paying attention to what’s getting used in the dishes.   Before, I’d mindlessly ripe open a box for a quick-and-easy meal solution.

I had a great idea. Why not try to make Nutella from scratch to try to reduce the sugar content? Typically there are only 3 ingredients in the recipe.  It couldn’t take too much prep time.  So, I set out on a mission to create homemade Nutella and use my 9-year old as my guinea pig.  My daughter told me it was ok.  She didn’t want me to go through too much trouble.  The Nutella she eats tastes just fine.  I told her it isn’t the taste about which I’m concerned, it’s the sugar content.  My goal was to produce my version of Nutella, with much less sugar, without sacrificing the flavor.

I found a recipe on a site I now frequent often, Real Food Digest(natural eating in a processed world).  My prayers were answered.  A Quick Homemade Nutella recipe with JUST THREE INGREDIENTS.

I only needed to purchase Almond Butter as I had the other two ingredients.

Nutella taste test samples

First homemade batch of the Nutella: I mistakenly used crunchy almond butter.  According to my kids, the first bite was good but, then it tasted too nutty and there wasn’t enough chocolate flavor.

Back to the store for creamy almond butter.

Second homemade batch of Nutella: was a lot tastier, a little less nutty but still, not creamy enough (even though I added Coconut Oil to the mixture to try to change the consistency).

Third homemade batch: I went out on a limb, closer to that of Laura Ingall’s Wilder.  I decided I’d make my own hazelnut butter.  I’d roast some hazelnuts in the oven for 10 minutes at 400 degrees and then grind them in the food processor until they formed a paste (don’t be too impressed, I didn’t dream this up, I followed instructions I found).  I also added in a bit more maple syrup.  Jackpot. Round three was almost right on the money. Smooth and creamy, a little sweeter tasting than the first two rounds.  It even looked more like Nutella.  Using the hazelnut butter instead of the almond butter made all the difference and diluted the spread’s nutty taste to enhance the chocolate flavor from the cocoa.

sea of hazelnuts ready to be chopped into hazelnut butter

I’m thrilled I made the effort to go natural with Nutella.

It’s so easy, there’s really no reason we shouldn’t try and make these small changes.

Does this mean we’re going to sanitize our kitchen and pantry of any sign of potentially processed food?  Realistically, no.

But, as a family, we’re going to be more aware and make our own attempts at healthy eating. And that feels great!

Do you make your own foods from scratch at home to avoid processed alternatives?  When you shop, are you reading labels to determine which items to purchase?

Winning homemade Nutella mix. Hazelnuts. Hazelnuts. Hazelnuts.



  1. I am definitely trying this one. It’s interesting to me how Nutella, I guess because it’s somehow vaguely European, seems quasi-healthy to people. My babysitter was making afterschool Nutella sandwiches for my kids and thinking it was this virtuous snack because it was on whole wheat bread. I had to point out that the kids did call it “chocolate sauce,” and that was pretty much exactly what it was. Palm-oily, sugary, chocolatey goodness. Like Betty Crocker in a saucepan on low.

    So I can’t wait to try this one! (probably won’t roast my own hazelnuts though…)

    • Amy » ooh Amy…. i had a response from a reader that challenged my experiment and panicked me. Find out what I found out when I asked a fellow nutritionist to weigh in as to whether my homemade version is actually healthier after all. Tomorrow’s post!

  2. Amy – after i went through this experiment, I was talking with a friend and realized (panicked) that maybe my homemade versions wasn’t any healthier at all due to the sugar in the honey/maple syrup. I reached out to a good friend who’s a dietician and asked her to review my method. My post tomorrow helps demystify the term “homemade.” Good thing, she voted for my version versus the store bought.


  1. […] week in my “Natural with Nutella” post, I was so giddy.  I made three different homemade dairy-free versions of Nutella!  I […]

  2. […] to take matters in my own hands and continue my homemade streak.  After all, as I learned with my Nutella experiment, when you’re in control and aware of each and every ingredient being used in a recipe, […]

  3. […] recipe is not to be filed under my “quest to find a healthier alternative,” like the Nutella and the Caramel Corn. But, you do get kudos for the home made […]

  4. […] means “dainty” or “tasty.” After becoming somewhat obsessed with making homemade Nutella spread, a cake with crushed hazelnuts adorning its top sounded […]

  5. […] The cookies use ground nuts for flavor, either almonds and hazelnuts.  Since my daughter loves nutella, I suspected the odds of her liking these cookies were […]

  6. Nutella Bars says:

    […] Peanut Bars. Last week we celebrated National Nutella Day all week long.  We remade our favorite homemade nutella, ate nutella and challah for breakfast, enjoyed nutella and strawberries for snacks, and we […]

  7. […] The cookies use ground nuts for flavor, either almonds and hazelnuts.  Since my daughter loves nutella, I suspected the odds of her liking these cookies were […]

  8. […] The cookies use ground nuts for flavor, either almonds and hazelnuts.  Since my daughter loves nutella, I suspected the odds of her liking these cookies were […]

Speak Your Mind